HookedFishing

Eagle Nest Lake

Moreno Valley, New Mexico: rainbows, kokanee, perch and pike at 8,200 feet

Surface Area
2,400 acres
Max Depth
80 ft
Elevation
8,200 ft
Ice-Out
April – May
Prime Season
May, Jun, Sep, Oct

Overview

Eagle Nest Lake sits at 8,200 feet in the Moreno Valley of northern New Mexico, on the Enchanted Circle between Angel Fire and Red River, with Wheeler Peak, the state's highest point, on the skyline. The lake is a reservoir on the Cimarron River; the river leaves through Eagle Nest Dam and drops into Cimarron Canyon, where it becomes one of New Mexico's better wild brown trout streams. Eagle Nest Lake State Park manages the shoreline, ramp and campground. The fishery is built on stocking: rainbow trout and kokanee salmon from state hatcheries, with kokanee eggs collected each fall to supply Heron, Navajo and Eagle Nest. Yellow perch are abundant, and northern pike, never intended to be here, have become established; the state wants them gone, so there is no limit on pike and none may be returned to the water. Ice-off comes in April or May, and the weeks that follow are the best fly fishing of the year, with rainbows cruising the shallows for scuds, midges and leeches. Callibaetis carry the summer from May into September, and afternoon thunderstorms make mornings the working hours. Kokanee are a trolling fish through summer; from October 1 through December 31 the lake opens to snagging, and in winter both kokanee and perch come through the ice. Wind is the constant: the valley is wide and open, and a float tube can be a long way from shore in a hurry.

Hatching now · October

Chironomid/Midge, Leech, Kokanee at peak

  • Chironomid/Midge

    PEAK
    • Red Chironomid #14-16
    • Black Chironomid #14-16
    • Zebra Midge #14-18
  • Leech

    PEAK
    • Woolly Bugger #6-8
    • Marabou Leech #6-8
  • Kokanee

    PEAK
    • Carey Special #10-12
    • Doc Spratley #10
    • Bead-Head Attractor #12
  • Scud

    ACTIVE
    • Olive Scud #14-16
    • Orange Scud #14-16
    • Flashback Scud #16

Angler reports

No reports on Eagle Nest Lake yet

File a report

Hatch chart

Twelve months on Eagle Nest Lake

Month-by-month insect activity for Eagle Nest Lake
InsectJFMAMJJASOND
Chironomid/MidgeJanuary: absentFebruary: absentMarch: absentApril: activeMay: peakJune: peakJuly: activeAugust: activeSeptember: peakOctober: peakNovember: activeDecember: absent
CallibaetisJanuary: absentFebruary: absentMarch: absentApril: absentMay: activeJune: peakJuly: peakAugust: peakSeptember: activeOctober: absentNovember: absentDecember: absent
DamselflyJanuary: absentFebruary: absentMarch: absentApril: absentMay: absentJune: activeJuly: peakAugust: peakSeptember: activeOctober: absentNovember: absentDecember: absent
LeechJanuary: absentFebruary: absentMarch: absentApril: activeMay: peakJune: peakJuly: activeAugust: activeSeptember: peakOctober: peakNovember: activeDecember: absent
KokaneeJanuary: absentFebruary: absentMarch: absentApril: absentMay: absentJune: absentJuly: activeAugust: activeSeptember: peakOctober: peakNovember: activeDecember: active
ScudJanuary: absentFebruary: absentMarch: absentApril: activeMay: activeJune: activeJuly: activeAugust: activeSeptember: activeOctober: activeNovember: activeDecember: absent
PeakActiveAbsent

Timing checked against

Chironomid (Fly Shack: midges mid-April to mid-November; Fly Shack lodge: midges deep in Nov-Dec, ice Jan-Mar), Callibaetis (Fly Shack: May-Sept) and Leech (lodge: buggers at ice-out, leeches deep Nov-Dec) match our chart. Fly Shack shows damselfly May-Nov, wider than our Jun-Sep, but that was not changed because the lodge guide gives no damsel timing.

How to fish it

Techniques

  • Boat Fishing

  • Float Tube

  • Shore Fishing

Season and regulations

Eagle Nest Lake is open year round, including ice fishing when conditions allow, and the posted area near the dam is closed to fishing. New Mexico's general trout and salmon limit applies: 5 per day and 10 in possession of trout and kokanee combined. During the special snagging season, October 1 through December 31, kokanee may be snagged with a limit of 12 per day and 24 in possession; kokanee are the only species that may be snagged, and anything else foul-hooked must be released. Northern pike have no bag or possession limit at Eagle Nest and may not be intentionally returned to the lake. Yellow perch fall under the statewide warmwater limit.

A New Mexico fishing license is required at 12 and older, and the state park charges a day-use fee. Confirm current limits in the New Mexico Department of Game and Fish fishing rules before you go.

Facts checked against

Removed tiger trout and brown trout from the lake's species list (state sources list stocked rainbows and kokanee plus yellow perch and northern pike) and the claim of a kokanee spawning run down the Cimarron below the dam, which the dam prevents. Removed the unsourced 'most productive stillwater in New Mexico' and size figures. Confirmed 8,200 feet, the Cimarron outflow, the October 1 to December 31 snagging season and the no-limit pike rule.